Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompt part 1 : 2003 Student Answers Questions 2

Sample YYY - This essay focuses on the satire, irony, and how society effect plays a on two "lovers" or soon to be married couples within The Other Paris. The first paragraph gives examples of how a man proposals to a woman whom she accepts even though, they only had known each other for three weeks and only speak about office talk. Showing how  The Other Paris starts by giving the reader a little insight of what's happening. Which i really liked about this , since i haven't read the book before it gave me a little taste of how things are. The second paragraph argues that marriage without love is going to fall apart. Providing support of how pressure and society, creates the thoughts of having to married, which the author explains how ironic that is. This really adds to the essay in my opinion, just as the AP Scoring of this had said  helps supports the author's point. The author also stays consistent in providing evidence to support his thoughts relating to how ironic the book is, staying on topic and engaging the reader. Lastly the final paragraphs of  essay, the author connects the mockery and irony of the institution surrounding marriage. I think the author wrote a fantastic essay, agreeing with the AP Scorers.

Sample CCC - This essay clearly focuses of how the power society has over individuals from  The Other Paris. This essay gives a short clear  summary of what happens, Not giving any unnecessary detail that distracts the reader from the main idea of the essay. The author stays consistent on proving specific quotations from the novel to support her. The author also provides good transitions creating really good flow as the reader is moving from paragraphs. This essay clearly expresses the author's idea, short, clear, and straight to the main ideas and comes full circle relating the conclusion by the the introduction paragraph.

Sample JJJ - The essay begins with a concept where the characters from The Other Paris is forced into marriage by narrative voice and social commentary. The writers first paragraph explains why the narrative voice gives a personal feel, but how does that connect to the writers idea of the two characters being forced into marriage. Maybe being off topic doesn't really help anything. The second paragraph explains why the social commentary by providing a quote and explaining how the character is insure. Stating how it alone creates the character's"insecurity of society" i though the essay could have used more detail of support explain the idea of why social commentary and the narrative voice causes them to be forced marriage, Which i kind of need to work on as well. Overall the essay just needs to present the idea clearly maybe just leaving it at the end of the intro. paragraph? But i could tell the  idea was  present but needs more support like provide some examples from the text or say what your thoughts of that was.

3 comments:

  1. Davis,
    You seem to comprehend the structure for each of the student essays that you read. My few bits of nonsense, eh, advice follow one simple thing really. Response. Your response. For the three essays that I read,one, I hate to say this, was quite terrible. Like, I couldn't read it because I was overwhelmed and a little scared because the writer failed. Terribly. Respond to their scores. Sample CCC sounds like it was a good paper. Sample JJJ...I'm assuming my word "terrible" fits in here? Anyway, just tell your readers and yourself really how the student essays made you feel. Did any specific technique stick out to you? Did the students follow the prompt? Did one do better proving one point than another? How can reading their essays benefit you when you have to write yours? Scary, I know.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Davis,
    I agree with Ludia in writing a bit of your own opinion into your responses. Additionally, your analysis of samples YYY and JJJ seem to summarize a bit too much. You can focus on what the student writer did in a paragraph, explaining how this built on to the rest of the essay and helped build the writer's point. Your analysis of CCC is a good example of how you can look at the essay. You can explain how these different points and flourishes then add to the essay as a whole. I might be asking for too much, and the students you are reading of aren't exactly Shakespeares. But I hope its a good thing to think about. You can also add what the writer actually got, and reflect on why the writer may have received such a score. After all, 9-scorers aren't exactly Shakespeares either.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You made it clear which student had the best, average, and worst essay. You are able to identify that Student YYY’s essay focuses on satire, irony, and the societal effects on the relationship between two characters. I would agree that Student CCC, while not as diverse in topics, provided solid evidence to justify her thesis. I also agree with you that Student JJJ had incoherent evidence. A specific example you used was when the student discusses the “personal feel” of the narrator’s voice as evidence that a character was forced into marriage. It was great that you incorporated an example of the student’s lacking focus because I was able to think to myself “Oh, yeah I remember that. It didn’t make sense.” My suggestions are similar to Curtis and Ludia’s in that you could have provided more solid evidence (instead of just your perception) and the students’ scores. Another piece of advice, sometimes you misuse words that are spelled similarly as another word that would be better suited (i.e. “ Proving support” should be swapped out with Providing support). I suggest disabling T9word or “word guessing” devices to improve the flow of your writing.

    ReplyDelete