Sunday, December 22, 2013

Response to Course Material

Let it snow, let it snow, let it snow.... Experiencing a lot of snow since the last Course Material, The weather had really took a turn for the cold. Although that also means more Snowdays! Anyways, We have spent all of our time focusing on Hamlet since the last response to course material post post. We read the play in class together, then watched parts of multiple versions of the movie, and read poems/articles on it. After the first reading of the play, my thoughts on it definitely changed while watching the different versions of Hamlet. 

It was interesting watching each version, they highlighted different things in the play. Showing that different people have different perspectives on things. I really liked the setting for the Branaugh and Tennet versions. I thought that they both showed how there was always spying in Elsinore and the idea that there is something wrong there. For the Jacobi version, the casting was really well done, compared to the other ones, especially for Laertes. I also liked the casting in the Hawke version too, but Hawke’s Hamlet seemed to be monotone. He lacked in complexity being really depressed and that no other emotion was really apparent in the movie. The play in general, lets us discover something new every time you read it or watch it again.  

Moving on to the poems/articles. Starting with the Tiv and their interpretation of the play Hamlet. They show that people do have different perspectives because we were born different in different cultures. They show how subjective interpretations are and how the "true" meaning behind things can really be said by the one who wrote it. The other two pieces of the forums was the Rimbaud's poem and the story about the prisoners. The Rimbaud's poem brought to mind of who to blame for Ophelia's death and if there really was anyone to blame for suicide? As for the prisoners, It was cool and surprising in a sense of how they could connect to the characters of the play of Hamlet. Which brought a new sense of emotions of expressing the play. 

Overall these were pretty interesting and it really brought changes to new ideas about this One Famous Play, Hamlet. Can you believe, we're almost half way done with school? Time really flies doesn't it? And Finals is really creeping up to us!

Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt 2004 Question 3

Sample N- Score 8: This is a very well written essay. The student addresses the prompt in the essay and had provided good support. Another, is that i liked how the student uses the plot create a statement. Student N was also able to use the plot summary to further their argument. This student also had deep understanding of Candide. They were able to prove their thesis with a lot of different examples from the text. The student could have labeled some of the literary terms a little clearer but they were still there. Other than that this was a very good response.

Sample J – Score 6: Although this essay was good it could room for improvement. The student clearly has a good point but they can't quite get there. They do not give us concrete evidence to let us get a better understanding. The student starts each argument and it seems like it will be a good point. However, that is as far as it goes. If the student explained their ideas it would have been a great essay. Also, the student uses very simple sentence structure and  very simple language. Making the argument sound less convincing. If students use elevated diction that would helped create a better argument for the readers mind. The student made some solid points but they needed to go further into the argument with examples.

Sample U – Score 3: Student U had the right idea but lacked a lot. The essay started off well. Their introductory paragraph was excellent. The thesis was clear and they had some good ideas being presented. The student used good word choice to make their argument sound intelligent in the first paragraph. However, that was as good as it got. The student failed to provide any sort of evidence for their claim. I was often confused when I was reading the body paragraphs. The ideas do not flow in a logical order to help the reader understand their argument. Meaning strong evidence could have helped a lot. The student needs to use more literary language and points to prove their thesis.

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Madonna's tone-deaf tattoo

     In her article, “Madonna’s Tone-Deaf Tattoo,” Meghan Daum remarks on a recent incident where pop singer Madonna revealed a new fake tattoo during a concert. Emblazoned on her lower back was the name of Malala Yousafzai, the young Pakistani girl who has gained a lot of recent media attention after being shot by members of the Taliban. The article carries a strongly negative tone that ridicules Madonna and attacks her tattoo. Daum uses pejorative diction to style Madonna as obnoxious, which goes in sharp contrast to the honorific diction she uses to endear readers to Malala. The language throughout is very sardonic, often used to mock Madonna. Also, Daum’s deliberate choice of details highlights many of Malala’s good deeds while bringing up ugly things from Madonna’s history.

     The article uses a very sardonic language that mocks Madonna. With the very first line in the article, “There goes Madonna, classing up the joint again,” Daum immediately sets the sardonic tone of the article, making it clear that Madonna is not going to get much love from her. It doesn’t get much more sarcastic than saying someone is “classing up the joint.” By calling Madonna the “Hottest Bod in the AARP,” Daum gives Madonna a backhanded compliment, more of an insult than a real compliment. It’s a demeaning title for Madonna, meant to ridicule and dismiss any remnants of her status as a sex symbol. Daum again ridicules Madonna’s tattoo as pathetic and ineffective against the Taliban. She says, “Take that Taliban! Mess with a girl’s education and you’re messing with a 54-year-old pop star in a leather corset.”  The sardonic and belittling language that Daum uses throughout the article doesn’t do anything to flatter the pop singer. Instead, readers get the sense that Madonna is classless and grossly promiscuous.
            
    Daum also uses diction to put critical labels on Madonna, while putting positive ones on Malala. She says Madonna has an “obsession with her body.” She calls Madonna an “extremist.” She describes Madonna’s tattoo-exposing as “relentless self-promotion” and “envelope pushing.” All of these words carry negative connotations for Madonna that depict her as obnoxious. On the other hand, Daum describes Malala’s face as “earnest” and “un-primmed.” She refers to Malala as a “modest Muslim girl.” Although these words don’t directly praise Malala’s character as fervently as Daum’s criticism of Madonna does, they highlight some of Malala’s qualities that endear the reader to young girl. Daum’s choice of diction in this article is subtle, but it still does enough to influence the reader.

     Through her deliberate choice of details, Daum gives unflattering stories and examples of Madonna’s actions to depict her as disgraceful. For example, the article mentions that Madonna “superimposed a swastika on the forehead of French politician Marine Le Pen.” It mentions that she “called President Obama a ‘black Muslim’ while ‘endorsing’ him at a performance.”  Yet, the details that Daum chose to leave out of the article are just as meaningful as the details she chose to include. Madonna has had a long, successful career as a singer. Like many pop singers, Madonna has done volunteer work, charity concerts, and fundraisers. But of course, Daum doesn’t mention any of this. Why? This article is supposed to be explaining why Madonna’s stunt is inappropriate, as the article title suggests. By highlighting a lot of the stupid, ugly things that Madonna has done, Daum paints a negative picture of Madonna.

     In contrast, Daum chooses to highlight certain details about Malala that depict her as a virtuous person. For example, the article mentions that Malala has written a blog for BBC. It mentions that she was the first ever to receive Pakistan’s National Youth Prize. It mentions that “Desmond Tutu nominated her for an International Children's Peace Prize.” These impressive accolades definitely make Malala a respectable and morally righteous young girl.
            In the article, not only does Daum express her disgust with Madonna’s tattoo, but she also reveals her disgust with the pop singer in general. This is clear in her heavy use of sardonic language, negative diction, and biased choice of details to define and describe Madonna.