Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt 2004 Question 3

Sample N- Score 8: This is a very well written essay. The student addresses the prompt in the essay and had provided good support. Another, is that i liked how the student uses the plot create a statement. Student N was also able to use the plot summary to further their argument. This student also had deep understanding of Candide. They were able to prove their thesis with a lot of different examples from the text. The student could have labeled some of the literary terms a little clearer but they were still there. Other than that this was a very good response.

Sample J – Score 6: Although this essay was good it could room for improvement. The student clearly has a good point but they can't quite get there. They do not give us concrete evidence to let us get a better understanding. The student starts each argument and it seems like it will be a good point. However, that is as far as it goes. If the student explained their ideas it would have been a great essay. Also, the student uses very simple sentence structure and  very simple language. Making the argument sound less convincing. If students use elevated diction that would helped create a better argument for the readers mind. The student made some solid points but they needed to go further into the argument with examples.

Sample U – Score 3: Student U had the right idea but lacked a lot. The essay started off well. Their introductory paragraph was excellent. The thesis was clear and they had some good ideas being presented. The student used good word choice to make their argument sound intelligent in the first paragraph. However, that was as good as it got. The student failed to provide any sort of evidence for their claim. I was often confused when I was reading the body paragraphs. The ideas do not flow in a logical order to help the reader understand their argument. Meaning strong evidence could have helped a lot. The student needs to use more literary language and points to prove their thesis.

2 comments:

  1. Hey Davis,
    I liked that you included the scores of each student, made suggestions for improvement, and recognized the pros/cons of each essay. I did this Open Prompt so I remember what the question was, but you should include the question in your blog. Another word of advice is to include quotes from the essays just for extra evidence.

    ReplyDelete
  2. At the beginning it would be good if you put the question. For your responses, if you added more examples from the writing I think that it would strengthen them more. Another point, last one I promise, is to response on whether or not you agree with the score that the student was given, or would you give another score. When you mention in your first response how the student uses the plot to create a statement I thought that this was an important point to make. Reading all of these essays really helps in understanding what the AP exam would want and you did a good job of pointing out some specifics. For the second response you mention diction, another important aspect of the AP exam. Lastly, you stayed strong with your response in the third paragraph. You did a great job, but I would put more examples in from the actual essays to add to the overall response.

    ReplyDelete