Sunday, October 13, 2013

Close Reading 10/13/13

How bad would a U.S. default be?

In this article from CNN explains about the the negative outcome would be if the U.S. would have a default which is defined to be a failure to pay financial debts. "In six days, the United States government's borrowing authority will be exhausted" meaning within six days the United States would not have the power to borrow money anymore, meaning they would be short on money to pay their debts. The author of this article uses a statement as an attention grabber. The author uses detail from facts to allow the reader to understand what's happening, for example, if the debt limit doesn't expand to be able to borrow more money, "the Treasury department will be left with only its cash on hand" meaning they would only have to use the money they have and earned, not nearly enough to cover the money needed for all the "payments" the Treasury makes.
The author uses provides lots of detail and facts to provide his point throughout this article giving examples of what programs that going to be affected by the unavailable cash if Congress doesn't extend the debt limit. Not providing factual detail lessens the point the author is trying to make. This is that if Congress doesn't act soon, the U.S. would be near to default. Which is funny because the author doesn't really include why the Congress wouldn't extend the debt limit, the author excludes the opposing side of the story on not extending the debt limit, like to include and refute within the article? Do you think the author did this on purpose to not let the reader get distracted from his argument?
     The diction of this article is colloquial diction, mostly everyday language because being a news article; it has to be a language everyday people would have to understand. The author also uses mostly concreteness words, so the readers are able to know exactly what the author is talking about like "Financial crisis", "Stock Market", "Treasuries", etc... Although the denotation and connotation is not really displayed much throughout other than mostly saying that the conditions would be bad if Congress doesn't do this. Examples of really good word choice is when the author uses adverbs in this paragraph " As in the last financial crisis, falling confidence would have ripple effects, affecting other markets including the short-term lending used by companies to finance themselves. This would all dampen economic growth, which is still not as strong as we would like in the wake of the last crisis." I really liked how the author used dampen as a connotation to help his point because dampen seems like a word that means lowering or make less of something when the author uses that within that paragraph.
     Towards the end of the article the author lists of what could possibly happen in a chained affect "The stock market would weaken, and retirement savings would dip. And of course unemployment would rise. Meanwhile, the inability to pay the rest of the government's regular obligations in full or on time would be spreading its own hardship across the economy" That's really good facts, but why would all these things happen? Maybe the author could explain all the examples and why these things happen.  How would we know if the fact he's stating is true or not if he doesn't explain to support, even though it would tie to Congress not extending the debt. What do you think the author should do?



http://www.cnn.com/2013/10/11/opinion/patterson-government-default/index.html?iid=article_sidebar

5 comments:

  1. Davis,
    You used a good variety of literary terms in this blog post. Specifically, I think your showed a strong understanding of colloquial diction and the connotation of the word "dampen". I am a little unsure if "financial crisis" is a concrete phrase--i think it is more abstract. This is due to the fact that the severity of the crisis is open to interpretation. However, in the article, as you mentioned, the author makes sure to provide facts and examples to show the dire consequences that would ensue if Congress were to fail in extending the debt limit. I can see that you are analyzing the news and are not just absorbing all the information that it thrown at you. Being an inquisitive reader is never a bad thing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While it is clear that you read your article thoroughly, and made a valiant effort to analyze it, there are a few technical errors with this post. For example, your very first sentence has some excess words. You don't need to write "in" at the beginning of the sentence, and you also don't need "about the" after "explain." To correct these simple mistakes, I would suggest reading your blog post out loud before you post it. This helps to catch mistakes that you wouldn't otherwise catch if you just read it over in your head because when you do that, often your brain fixes the errors in your head. Also, you often write questions like you're interacting with the reader. While I enjoy this, as it keeps me engaged, Ms. Holmes would like these posts to be solely analytical in nature, so try to avoid the questions in the future. Other than that, I think that you bring up a lot of interesting points about this article, just remember to proofread!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Davis--The close reading posts are meant as practice for the AP test, so they are structured as analytical pieces, just like an AP test essay, and are written in formal academic voice, just like the AP test.

      Delete
  3. Davis--I have several concerns about this essay. Can we meet in FLEX, please?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Davis,
    I agree that the author doesn’t really include the other side of the story but I think this is partially because of the article is an opinion piece. I do think the author did this on purpose because of this. The author seemed to be expressing his views that he thought were right. I’m pretty sure that he did do this on purpose because he thought his views were right and thought the other side was wrong. I think that the author should try to explain his arguments more it would help people understand the consequences defaulting more. I agree that the author uses details in the article. I think that it can be debated whether the diction used is colloquial. I think between colloquial and elevated diction. There is vocabulary used that is more elevated. I don’t think that literature can always fit into one of the categories of diction. I agree that the author uses good word choice. You also need to analyze at least 3 of the 5 (diction, imagery, details, language, and syntax) in the close reading.

    ReplyDelete