In this article, the question of apologies is brought up about President Obama. John Dickerson the author of this article discusses his opinion on President Obama apologizing without taking responsibility first by letting the reader have a taste of what the opposing side is talking about and then refuting it with examples that support his side. While doing so, he uses the techniques of Diction, Imagery, and Syntax.
The diction within this piece is a mix between colloquial diction
and elevated diction. The author starts the article with colloquial diction to
give a sense of understanding the article easier to readers because of the wide
range of people that could be reading it for the first paragraph. Moving on to
the second paragraph the author begins writing in elevated diction by
demonstrating more connotational words like "responsibility" and
"accidentally". Within the seventh paragraph all the word
choices the author uses adds a sense of worry to what he is saying. Adding a
more effective effect in supporting his claims; "the kind of worry the
president passes the law to diminish .... When you have no insurance, it's
frightening...." the author also uses repetition to make that feeling more
dramatic.
The imagery the author uses in the second paragraph allows you to
picture what's happening within the scene. "When you accidentally brain
another customer at the market reaching for a bottle of wine, you rush to say
you're sorry." explaining the "custom dictates" that we automatically
do. Then the author gives a lot more examples of other situations on where this
occurs and later adds an idea into the readers head to "Question"
whether the Apologies are meaningful. Another is in paragraph five; the author
uses the reference of "bubble-wrap" to create an image of the
President covering his problem with "lots of explanations and
rationalizations". The word choice the author uses also create an image of
a negative effect for the President.
"When your apology sputters out at the end of a list of
mitigating conditions, it lacks much punch. It seems grudging." the
sentence pretty much says if your apology randomly comes out after many other
excuses it lessens the effect.
The syntax creates an impact effect for the readers through the
use of sentence fragments. Near the end of paragraph one, the author writes
"It didn't work for him. All doors were locked." creating a dramatic
effect that the president is trapped and had no other choice. Another is within
paragraph six. The use of the sentence fragments is manipulative; implanting an
idea into our heads and creating an emphasis on refuting through a series of
question and answer. "It lacks much punch. It seems grudging. So do the
people going through this feel better? Probably not. Does it look like the
president was trying to make himself look better? Yes, it does."
The use of literary devices meaning mostly the use of hyperboles
is shown throughout the article, mostly near the beginning or the end of each
paragraph the authors wrote. Starting with the first paragraph the author jumps
right into using a hyperbole " These people - the Associated press says
there are more than 3.5 million of them - are losing their plans.." using
this to exaggerate the sentence that is totally not necessary but lets the
reader know that its "going to" effect a lot of people because of
this plan. Another literary device that was used was repetition forcing in the
idea of something being "frightening" in paragraph eight “When you
have no insurance, it's frightening. When you worry you'll be dropped from your
insurance, it's frightening. When you worry you'll be dropped from your
insurance, it's frightening. When you might go bankrupt because the plan you
have won't truly cover your bills when you get sick, that's frightening.” The
author uses this to explain the feeling of losing your insurance because of the
policies the president had making it more dramatic and more impacting
repeatedly using the word "Frightening".
Davis,
ReplyDeleteI really like the way you've written your piece. It's clear and concise, going straight to the point. I like the realization you made about the author's transition from colloquial diction to elevated. I think a lot of journalists do this specifically for the reason you stated: that some readers stop at the first paragraph and read no further. You clearly obtained many examples for demonstrating the imagery in the article, something I think a lot of students don't do because imagery is tough to figure out. I think your examples of syntax are also great and clearly show the fragmented sentences the author used. Overall, I think your close reading is excellent, though I'd like to see a concluding paragraph.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Davis,
ReplyDeleteYou clearly took the feedback we gave last time into account. Good close reading over all, there are just a few aspects that you might want to improve on. You had a good introduction that gave a quick introduction to the article, and then told the reader what you were going to discuss in the body. Next time you might want to mention the overall meaning that was created by the different literary techniques. Also one side not, you don’t have to capitalize the words diction, imagery, and syntax. You did a good job of supporting your claims with quotes. I’m not sure if you want to use first person considering that this is supposed to be like a formal essay. I would recommend proofreading your post; there were some mistakes that took away from your close reading. Overall, good job.
Nice work Davis. This post clearly showcases your knowledge of literary techniques and the ways in which they can create tone. Your intro sets up your argument with a distinct thesis statement that leaves no doubt as to what your essay will deal with. I noticed that you cited repitition as an example of diction, when they would probably fit more effectively as evidence in your body paragraph about syntax. I also found a few grammatical and spelling mistakes that would have been easy fixes with another proofread. Nothing too distracting, but a quick read-through would reduce the likelihood of technical mistakes detracting from the professionalism of your work. I love your analysis of the author's syntax. You were really able to dig deep into what can be the trickiest letter in the DIDLS acronym. The sentence fragmentation you identified was a prime example, though one or two more pieces of evidence may have been helpful for supporting your claim. Lastly, I'm not sure if the example you used for Hyperbole is actually a hyperbole. Might want to review the context of that line, because I'm pretty sure there are at least 3.5 million Americans struggling with the new health care system. Anyway, good stuff Davis.
ReplyDelete