It’s already near the end of November and I’m doing the 3rd
reflection. Time really flies by this year. Ohhh and it’s the reflection right
before Thanksgiving break!!! The "Breaks" are starting to approach us
but before all that happens, the reflection of all the things we've done in
class.
One of the things we did in class was doing a second attempt of
the poem "Century Quilt" after Ms. Holmes had pointed out some key
parts within the essay. I have to admit that I actually felt kind of bad when I
found out all the things I missed compared to analyzing the "Century Quilt”
with the class. I didn't notice the different families within the poem and the
racism within it and how tragic the poem really is. But I did however figure the
references to death and how the "Century Quilt" had something to do
with generations. Overall I really liked the idea of being able to rewrite
essays, because we're able to improve and catch ideas that we missed the first
time around. I would like to have more of these because I think that they help
a lot with improving our skills in analyzing/writing essays.
Then the class moves on to finishing up discussing about the Death of a Salesman. Ms.
Holmes presented the idea of "fish bowling" where there are only a
few seats within the middle of the classroom surrounded by the other classmates
kind of like a fish within a fish bowl. Although unlike the regular
discussions, only the people within the fishbowl could talk about the given
prompted/question. I liked that it had maintained the focus on the prompt
questions and everyone within the fishbowl was able to participate. The one
thing I didn't like about it was that if someone outside of the fishbowl had
something they really wanted to say but wasn't able to because of the
limitations.
Exercises that expressed mood and atmosphere, by letting the class
decide on a picture and write about its mood and reflect on the picture had
captured. We had done one about a dark alley with a river in the middle, which
I thought we did really well on, describing the mood of how uninviting it was.
The second one we picked was a picture of 12 men. The difference with this was
that I found that the class had a hard time trying to precisely capture the
mood it was trying to depict about the tense and structure of how we're going
to do it, but eventually we pulled through. I'm sure it was probably because
some people were either tired or just wanted to be done with it and move on to
Hamlet.
The class has finally come to warping up the reading of Hamlet. The play is very fascinating with
its many twists and turns along with the witty dialogue. I also liked that we
had read the play out loud with the class because in doing so, we're able to comprehend
the play better. Especially when Ms. Holmes helps explain what we had just read
and helped us find the hidden intentions of each character. I found those
extreme helpful because when reading alone for the close reading, I think I
would of had a difficult time trying to decipher what Shakespeare had wrote.
Although I’ll be looking forward to what I find as I do the close reading
because maybe there’s something that the class missed? Since, there’s a saying
that if you read something again you could also gain a new perspective on it.
Nice response, Davis. It's clear that you're an active and engaged student. I like that you remembered to mention our work with the AP essay format, a part of our course material that many, including myself, forgot to include in their responses. By the way, I definitely shared your struggle to identify the various motifs within "The Century Quilt". For me, the majority of my preparation for the AP exam needs to be centered around closed prompt essays. Tricky stuff. With regards to your opinion of the fishbowl discussion style, I think the point of it is to limit participation and increase efficiency. Sometimes, when everyone is allowed to talk, the class can lose focus or disintegrate into smaller, fragmented discussions. For that purpose, I'm a big fan of this new departure from our traditional Socratic discussions. On a different note, you mentioned that your class struggled with the mood and atmosphere exercise, and I think to some degree each class had trouble with it. Aside from exhaustion, why do you think this was? I'm interested to know what about that activity you believe held up your class. For 6th hour, we got very nit-picky, and had a difficult time with our phrasing and word order. When writing such a brief description, that can be quite important, but it can also distract us from the larger objectives, and do little to establish tone. Anyway, nice work Davis.
ReplyDeleteDavis,
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you that the only thing about the fish bowl is that if you're not in it, you can't say anything. I was getting so frustrated during that time, since I had so much to say and was rarely given the opportunity to say it! I also agree that the second time we did the mood and atmosphere activity was harder than the first, for the same reasons. I think it was just hard for us to agree on what the picture of twelve men was displaying, whether it was tenseness or whatever the other word was. Did you think everyone was participating, though? Personally, I did not and I found that that was the biggest reason our class had such a difficult time. The fact that you mentioned Ms. Holme's helpfulness in stopping and giving us information that we otherwise would've missed is also great, since I noticed the same thing! It really helped with my annotations. Well done, Davis!
Hi Davis,
ReplyDeleteYou pretty much covered everything we did in class, good job doing that. I think that you should try to connect the different things with outside information. You summarized what we did, but we’re supposed to reprocess what we learned and try to make connections between the concepts and other things. I know it’s hard to not summarize, I’ve made the same mistake a lot. I think back to the discussions we had in class, when people might mention how some other book or movie related to what we’re learning. I try to expand on the connections and explain what they are. I hope this helps. Overall you did a good job with your response all you need to do is try to connect the different ideas more together or to other things.