Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt 2009 Question 3 (A Symbol)

Sample 3A - Score 9, I actually liked this essay and thought it was really well done and believe that this student clearly deserved his/her score. The student starts off with a thesis and sticks to it, throughout the entire essay, not going off topic or straying from the idea of how "The Wild Duck" symbolizes a message to the audience. The student also presents good transitions from paragraph to paragraph. For example starting the intro paragraph to first body paragraph the student writes "  a wild duck in order to highlight the events and development of the characters.." and going to " Over the course of the play, the Hjalmar family" and goes on to talk about the family. I also liked another thing about this essay and that is.... Organization, which probably gave this student free points: having a intro paragraph following up with a thesis and sticks to it,  Body paragraphs that sticks to the thesis, while providing a ton of insights to let know what kind of story the essay is about , and warping it nicely with a conclusion. I believe that this student deserved his/her score, and agreeing with the AP scorer, that the essay was “detailed analysis is thoughtful, well organized, and sophisticated".

Sample 3B - Score 6, this essay has some minor grammar issues, but that really doesn't distract the main ideas presented by the student. The essay in my opinion was fine; the student presented the idea of how the lampshade symbolizes that she cover up things and past experiences because of one incidence. Eventually, the character becomes untrusting that the reader can't believe anything the character said. The idea is present throughout the essay which I liked about it, but it could use some reinforcement. I feel like the essay just needs more detail and support to help convey the student's idea. “Blache’s obsession with putting a lampshade on light bulbs is on the surface just a vain attempt to hide her aging" why? Why does Blache want to hide her aging? Why is she uncomfortable with it? I also thought that the conclusion wasn't as strong as it could be but I did like that it came full circle and had brought the idea of her hiding the truth. Along with the reasons on why she did what she did.

Sample 3C - Score 4, to be honest I thought the essay was ok, just needs a few adjustments. This essay received its score for various reasons. Starting with how the author focuses mainly on how the machete symbolizes pride and strength, which is ok, but the student doesn't really go into depth with the meaning of the machete. I've also noticed that the essay lacked a lot of detail from the text to support his/her claims. In the second paragraph, “His machete was a defense mechanism to scare them off although in the end the Christian white folk won the battle...." how did he use it as a defense mechanism?? Did he swing it around when they got near or just attacked random "Christian white folk"? I also thought that the student strayed from the idea of symbolism in an in-depth way to describe the novel missing what the prompt was asking him/her to do. In the conclusion, the author does not provide any support for his claims, and I didn't think it counts as a conclusion. Especially when the student says “Okonko did not have the machete with him when he hung himself" and so he had "no pride" doesn't really warp anything together.   


4 comments:

  1. Nice critiques, Davis! Your understanding of what makes an essay effective in responding to an open prompt is apparent here. The first student was indeed very focused and well organized in their writing. Your claim regarding their transitions could have been valid, but I feel that the examples you provided don't particularly showcase that. It might be useful to reassess the transitions in order to identify which ones work really well in order to justify your scoring. I agree that the second essay was deserving of a mid-range score, and I liked the specificity of your critique. You asked thoughtful questions about Blanche's obsession that clearly illustrated the essay's lack of detail and evidence. However, you criticize the conclusion of the piece without providing any evidence of it's inferiority to the rest of the essay. What about the conclusion made it "not as strong" in your eyes? I think that's important to think about. In my opinion, the last essay's major flaw was its lack of textual evidence, which you also noted. On a side note, I think you may be using the word "warp" incorrectly. Might be worth looking up just to ensure that your critiques are clear. All in all, nice work. Keep it up, Davis!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nicely done, Davis! Your clear understanding of how to critique these essays is apparent in the amount of evidence you used and the detailed explanation of their wrongs and rights. I enjoyed your mention of the "small grammar errors" in the second student's writing, since most people don't pay attention to that, whereas I do and think it plays an important part in the well written-ness of the essay. I also like how you proved your point that the second student didn't give strong enough explanations for why Blache was attempting to hide her aging by asking questions like "why does Blache want to hide her aging?" However, you should ask the same questions yourself, such as when you state that the conclusion of the piece was "not as strong". Like you asked the student, ask yourself "why" the conclusion wasn't as strong, because you didn't make that clear. Overall, well done.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Davis,
    You had good critical responses to the open prompt. I liked that you mentioned what score each essay received and whether you agreed or disagreed with the score. I’m trying to do this more now. Essay 3A sounds like it was practically perfect and it deserved the 9 it got. Good job using quotes from the essay to back up your claims. Essay 3B seems to just need some more work. Then with essay 3C it sounds like the author didn’t really have in depth analysis and didn’t maintain focus throughout the essay. You do a good job again using quotes again in your analysis of the last two essays. I think you could have also used some evidence to back up that the conclusion was not very strong, and explained why. Overall, nicely done.

    ReplyDelete