Sunday, January 12, 2014

Open Prompt Part 2

2003. According to critic Northrop Frye, “Tragic heroes are so much the highest points in their human landscape that they seem the inevitable conductors of the power about them, great trees more likely to be struck by lightning than a clump of grass. Conductors may of course be instruments as well as victims of the divisive lightning.” Select a novel or play in which a tragic figure functions as an instrument of the suffering of others. Then write an essay in which you explain how the suffering brought upon others by that figure contributes to the tragic vision of the work as a whole.

Perhaps William Shakespeare's most revered play, Hamlet dominates all-around with its intricate characters, setting details, and plot. The titular character Hamlet definitely takes more time to develop and understand than all the rest because he has so many key functions, one of these being the suffering that he brings to the kingdom of Elsinore through his own despair. In this sense, Hamlet joins the ranks of other tragic heroes such as Jay Gatsby, as his madness, actions, and previous state destroy his father's kingdom from the inside out.

     First off, there is good reasoning to believe that Hamlet has gone entirely insane. His father's death and mother's quick re-marriage most likely to blame, he begins seeing ghosts that nobody else can see and even talking to himself about whether or not to kill himself as displayed in his famous "To be or not to be" soliloquy. During these ramblings, he contemplates whether or not to murder the king. Obviously as soon as the king catches wind of this he tries to remove Hamlet immediately, but in doing so he divides the love he shares with Gertrude, Hamlet's mom. Gertrude would never go against her son, but the king has no choice unless he really wants to take a chance on dying, so Hamlet's insanity preys on its first victim.

     Next, this sort of mental deterioration that Hamlet goes through drives him to murder, stabbing and killing Polonius while in Gertrude's closet. He proceeds to throw his mother around, scaring her to the point where she doesn't even recognize him anymore, yet she still wants to see the good in him. After all the physical pain Hamlet has caused for those around him through his actions, they still put their trust in him. This trust of course, only leads to the downfall of the queen and his childhood friends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. Not to mention that by taking Polonius's life, Hamlet indirectly drives Ophelia insane as well and pushes her to suicide. Now gone are several key players to Elsinore, most importantly the king's advisor.

     Finally, none of Hamlet's madness or actions would even have an effect without his previous standing in the kingdom. If Hamlet was a nobody, then the king could have just had him killed off the bat. The problem is that he is closely connected to a majority of Elsinore, leaving them vulnerable. Aside from his own mother, he has recently garnered a somewhat serious relationship with Ophelia and holds a lot of respect from his best friend Horatio. This connection causes him to absolutely devastate Ophelia through not only the public shaming, but also the murder of the one other person she trusts, her father. And although Horatio is able to remain aloof from the suffering during the play, he eventually gets hurt watching his dear friend Hamlet fade from life. One has to let their guard down to trust another, and that is exactly how Hamlet is able to function so well as a tragic hero.

2 comments:

  1. Davis,
    Firstly, I would like to compliment you how well-composed this post is: it is quite obvious that you know what you’re writing about. Even so, I have a few things to comment about. It seemed like your essay picked up steam in clarity as it got going; the later paragraphs were better than the former ones. The point you make in the first paragraph that Claudius and Gertrude’s relationship as husband and wife was strained by Hamlet’s apparent madness doesn’t seem to have much textual evidence, at least none that I found. I always saw Claudius as the one with total power over Gertrude and her decisions, including those about Hamlet, and since we never get to hear Gertrude’s inner thoughts, we can never be certain about her feelings on her marriage. Though, if I’m missing something in the text, please point me in the right direction. Your second paragraph hit the nail square on the head with examples that fit right in with the prompt. However, I don’t think your third paragraph is expansive as it could have been; you could’ve talked about how all of Denmark was affected as a result, what with Hamlet’s turning over control of the nation to a foreigner with only a few words, which could mean gigantic changes for the populous of Denmark. I didn’t find anything wrong with what you said in that paragraph, though. It is also good practice to write conclusions to these sorts of essays, though they are not essential, as timing may dictate, on the actual exam, whether or not we might get the chance to write one. They do make an essay better, though, and I think yours could’ve benefited from one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Davis,
    This post is quite well written. You exercise good command over language.
    You should organize your next post with a clearer thesis statement. Opening with a clear statement on what Hamlet's "tragic vision" is, and how the character fits in to it, would guide your response more tightly.
    Your analysis of Hamlet also seems to only touch on a surface-level understanding of the play. If you could elaborate more on the play's subtext, and demonstrate a more specific view on the play's meaning, I'm sure our imaginary AP Grader would bump up your score.
    It's also worth noting that you should add a concluding paragraph to the post's end, summarizing the ideas you've put forth. It gives the essay a more structured appearance, and shows the Grader that you put thought into its organization.

    ReplyDelete