Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompt 2


2008. In a literary work, a minor character, often known as a foil, possesses traits that emphasize, by contrast or comparison, the distinctive characteristics and qualities of the main character. For example, the ideas or behavior of a minor character might be used to highlight the weaknesses or strengths of the main character. Choose a novel or play in which a minor character serves as a foil for the main character. Then write an essay in which you analyze how the relation between the minor character and the major character illuminates the meaning of the work.

      The play Macbeth tells the story of a tragic hero Macbeth. He meets three witches who tell him his future and this leads to his downfall. He makes horrible decisions in an to attempt to gain power and become the King, including murder. His  best friend Banquo is a foil to Macbeth. Banquo's honor and his ability to ignore the witches basically foils Macbeth's need for power and obsession with the witches.

     Macbeth and Banquo meet three witches on their way home from war. Macbeth has just been a war hero and is to be honored by the king. The witches tell him he is going to be King and it is his destiny. The witches also tell Banquo that his future relatives will be King. The different reactions to the witches is the biggest difference between Macbeth and Banquo. Macbeth takes this as a challenge to make  this prophecy happen. He becomes consumed by the need to become King and gain power. He uses the witches words to defend murder. Banquo's reaction is the opposite. He does not trust the witches and chooses not to do anything about what they say. He even urges Macbeth to not listen to the witches. The different choices Banquo and Macbeth make highlight the mistakes that Macbeth makes. Because Macbeth does act on these ideas he leads to his own downfall while Banquo's children become king.
     
     Banquo also foils Macbeth's character. Banquo remains an honest and honorable man. He is offered by Macbeth a position in order to remain loyal and help Macbeth become king. Banquo does not chose to accept this unless he is promised that he will not be part of anything unmoral. He is given the opportunity to gain power and he chooses to remain true to himself. Macbeth on the other hand does not remain honorable through the play. When Macbeth is first introduced he is introduced as a war hero, a loyal soldier. When given the opportunity for power he seizes it and gives up his moral compass. He desires power and lets that dictate his decisions. Banquo remains honorable through out the play highlighting Macbeth's lack of morality.
     
     Macbeth tells the story of a man who loses his morality in order to gain power. He does this based on the foresight of three witches. His best friend Banquo provides a foil to this by remaining true to his honor and not following the witches. Banquo's traits help highlight Macbeth's mistakes and lack of moral judgement.  


                                                                                                                                        

3 comments:

  1. Davis,

    You do a good job illustrating how Macbeth and Banquo are foils, but you stopped there. This essay was mostly summary while the AP readers are looking for analysis. Write like the readers were in your class last year and read Macbeth with you, they know what the play is about. Rather than spending time providing a brief summary explain how the different reactions of Banquo and Macbeth influenced the play. You should also include a paragraph on meaning or explain after each paragraph how your claim adds to the meaning. You make large statements in your final sentences such as “the different choices Banquo and Macbeth make highlight the mistakes that Macbeth makes” but you don’t go on to elaborate them. Try prewriting next time to have a solid grasp of what you will be arguing. It is tough writing for AP readers since it’s unlike any essays we’ve ever written, but keep practicing and you’ll do great in May!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Davis!
    I like the structure of this post. You set up your intentions in your introductory paragraph, explore your argument in your two body paragraphs, and conclude nicely, making you post clear and easy to read.
    Ms. Holmes was careful to emphasize how our thesis paragraphs should serve as complete answers to the prompt, and I'm not sure your thesis fully does this. While you do introduce a work (Macbeth) and reference the two characters of this work that act as foils (Macbeth and Banquo), you omit the author of the work (William Shakespeare) and you leave out any reference to the play's meaning. This is an essential part of the prompt, and should serve as a launching point to demonstrate your understanding of the text. To the AP Grader, simply summarizing the plot of your chosen work isn't enough. You have to delve into the work's meaning, and show how well you understand this piece of literature.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think you have a good idea for a response to the prompt, but your intro paragraph is a bit weak. You don’t mention the author and the paragraph is mostly just summary of the play. You answer how Banquo is a foil for Macbeth, but you don’t write at all how this adds to the overall meaning of the play. At the end of the essay, you get closer to writing some sort of theme statement, but it’s not all the way there. Your two body paragraphs also contain a lot of summary. You are able to answer the how Banquo is a foil, but not more than that. I think it’s really important to remember that you always have to state the theme in a AP Lit exam essay. This isn't a bad essay, but just needs some more development.

    ReplyDelete