Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt 2004 Student Answers question 2

Student WWW
Like what AP scorer has said he writer stays constant in talking about the three characters the writer mentions about in their thesis. Then coming full circle explaining why all the literary devices create an "increasingly mocking" and ironic as the writer states in the thesis.  Although, I have to say that the writer uses quotes, fail to explain the quotes in-depth. Meaning using only direct quotes by themselves don't really help to analyze the meaning of a text, adding a sense to let the audience understand how the devices are being used within the quote to give the text meaning. I'm kind of surprised that the writer had gotten an 8 but it could be understandable, the student did stay on task, provided intro paragraphs, body paragraphs, and had a good conclusion. Even though I kind of think that the AP scorer only really looked at the conclusion of the piece because again the quotes used in this piece weren’t really explained well, maybe that's just me.

Student C
The Student provides clean statements about how Henry James creates contrasting characters that create a story. As this is the thesis of the whole paper, the Student does a nice a job of providing quotes and examples of support his or his points. Like in the first body paragraph, when the author explains the different classes of society from the two different characters. The Student does a great job of providing evidence to support their thesis statement. I also really liked how the Student wraps everything up and focus on the big picture of the essay. Although the writer does show a little lack of vocabulary, because there are some instances of some repetitive words. Maybe the Student didn't really follow the AP rubric about James's technique in writing; not answering the prompt could deem the Student with the score he/she had gotten from the AP scorer because you could only get so much from missing the major component of the AP scoring.

Student T
This Essay doesn't really provide a clear thesis statement, meaning it’s really hard to figure out what this essay is about. If the Student had provided a clear thesis statement the Student would have scored "better", adding to this, I found that the Student talks about what the author's thoughts and feelings as they wrote the "the pupil" and their favorite parts within the story. Which I think has no connection to what I think the thesis statement, "Pemberton, Mrs. Moreen, and the pupil are characterized with their personality and actions" is.
Also there seems to be missing words in some of the sentences or spelling errors, this makes the sentences sound a little weird. I would have to agree with the AP Scorer, that this essay only deserves a 3, due to the lack of analysis.


3 comments:

  1. It appears that you picked up on the positive and negative points of each student's essay. However, you did not use sufficient evidence to back up your claims. It would have been beneficial to your arguments to have actual quotes from each student's essay. Specifically for student WWW. This student received an 8 but, you thought they did not do a adequate job of explaining the quotes they pulled form the excerpt. Iwould have liked to have seen a specific example of the student falling short in their explanation, followed by your commentary on why it was not up to par.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I know I've said the same thing on the last two posts, but this time your technical errors are actually detrimental to the reading. I think you would see what I mean if you read this over. Fragment sentences, incorrect use of capitalization (or lack thereof, "I" should always be capitalized as a word!!!), and incorrect usage of apostrophes are some of the issues I see. I know that you are trying very hard to get your point out when analyzing these students, but it's very hard to follow with so many errors. It also would have been helpful to understand a tiny bit about the prompt before you throw the author's name around. Your opinions on the matter certainly make this more interesting to read, I agree with you that sometimes the AP readers seem to have gotten the score wrong -- often I see it as a bit too high for the essay, as do you. I can only hope that the AP readers round up on my essay, too, so maybe I shouldn't be so critical of these folks!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Davis,
    I think you accidentally did a closed prompt. In a closed prompt the piece of literature that the essay is about is already decided. In an open prompt the student is able to pick the piece of literature that the essay is about. I made the same mistake earlier. I would talk to Ms. Holmes about this; I hope you can still get credit for the response.
    I think the difference in the scores between Student WWW and Student C show how important it is to maintain focus on the prompt. Responding to prompt is very important and no matter how polished an essay is it can’t make up for not answering the question. It is also important to have a clear thesis that responds to the prompt and maintain the focus throughout the essay.

    ReplyDelete