In her
article, “Madonna’s Tone-Deaf Tattoo,” Meghan Daum remarks on a recent incident
where pop singer Madonna revealed a new fake tattoo during a concert.
Emblazoned on her lower back was the name of Malala Yousafzai, the young
Pakistani girl who has gained a lot of recent media attention after being shot
by members of the Taliban. The article carries a strongly negative tone that
ridicules Madonna and attacks her tattoo. Daum uses pejorative diction to style
Madonna as obnoxious, which goes in sharp contrast to the honorific diction she
uses to endear readers to Malala. The language throughout is very sardonic,
often used to mock Madonna. Also, Daum’s deliberate choice of details
highlights many of Malala’s good deeds while bringing up ugly things from
Madonna’s history.
The
article uses a very sardonic language that mocks Madonna. With the very first
line in the article, “There goes Madonna, classing up the joint again,” Daum
immediately sets the sardonic tone of the article, making it clear that Madonna
is not going to get much love from her. It doesn’t get much more sarcastic than
saying someone is “classing up the joint.” By calling Madonna the “Hottest Bod
in the AARP,” Daum gives Madonna a backhanded compliment, more of an insult
than a real compliment. It’s a demeaning title for Madonna, meant to ridicule
and dismiss any remnants of her status as a sex symbol. Daum again ridicules
Madonna’s tattoo as pathetic and ineffective against the Taliban. She says,
“Take that Taliban! Mess with a girl’s education and you’re messing with a
54-year-old pop star in a leather corset.”
The sardonic and belittling language that Daum uses throughout the
article doesn’t do anything to flatter the pop singer. Instead, readers get the
sense that Madonna is classless and grossly promiscuous.
Daum also uses diction to put
critical labels on Madonna, while putting positive ones on Malala. She says
Madonna has an “obsession with her body.” She calls Madonna an “extremist.” She
describes Madonna’s tattoo-exposing as “relentless self-promotion” and
“envelope pushing.” All of these words carry negative connotations for Madonna
that depict her as obnoxious. On the other hand, Daum describes Malala’s face
as “earnest” and “un-primmed.” She refers to Malala as a “modest Muslim girl.”
Although these words don’t directly praise Malala’s character as fervently as
Daum’s criticism of Madonna does, they highlight some of Malala’s qualities
that endear the reader to young girl. Daum’s choice of diction in this article
is subtle, but it still does enough to influence the reader.
Through
her deliberate choice of details, Daum gives unflattering stories and examples
of Madonna’s actions to depict her as disgraceful. For example, the article
mentions that Madonna “superimposed a swastika on the forehead of French
politician Marine Le Pen.” It mentions that she “called President Obama a ‘black
Muslim’ while ‘endorsing’ him at a performance.” Yet, the details that Daum chose to leave out
of the article are just as meaningful as the details she chose to include.
Madonna has had a long, successful career as a singer. Like many pop singers,
Madonna has done volunteer work, charity concerts, and fundraisers. But of
course, Daum doesn’t mention any of this. Why? This article is supposed to be
explaining why Madonna’s stunt is inappropriate, as the article title suggests.
By highlighting a lot of the stupid, ugly things that Madonna has done, Daum
paints a negative picture of Madonna.
In
contrast, Daum chooses to highlight certain details about Malala that depict
her as a virtuous person. For example, the article mentions that Malala has
written a blog for BBC. It mentions that she was the first ever to receive
Pakistan’s National Youth Prize. It mentions that “Desmond Tutu nominated her
for an International Children's Peace Prize.” These impressive accolades
definitely make Malala a respectable and morally righteous young girl.
In the article, not only does Daum
express her disgust with Madonna’s tattoo, but she also reveals her disgust
with the pop singer in general. This is clear in her heavy use of sardonic
language, negative diction, and biased choice of details to define and describe
Madonna.
Nice post Davis! I think you have improved over the months on your writing and understanding of DIDLS. My only critique would be when you discuss how the author's use of language suggested sarcasm. This author was very sarcastic about the seasoned pop-star; however, your evidence sounded like it would've fit better supporting the author's use of tone. The only reason I say this is because the entire article does not seem to be a satire because there are direct attacks made on Madonna and the author does establish that Malala Yousafzai is benevolent.
ReplyDeleteYour response was really well done! The different DIDLS that you mentioned are important in such articles. When you talk about language, you gave a lot of good examples from the text. It helped me understand your argument more and I think helped your response overall. Like what Audrey said, you talk more about tone than language. The tone mocks Madonna more than the language does. The language can contribute to the tone of the piece and I think that if you make that argument to use language it would get the point across. When you talk about diction, you again gave a lot of great examples. The piece did use the diction to enhance the negativity of the overall writing as well as the details. I felt like in the last two paragraphs you really did a great job analyzing the piece and with so many examples it made the response really good. Great job again!
ReplyDelete